Home/Blog/Adult Psychology/Breathing Exercises and Anxiety: What Works, What Doesn't?
Psychologist Ethem Tozbay
Psychologist Ethem Tozbay
Adult Psychology10 min readUpdated:
Summarize:

Breathing Exercises and Anxiety: What Works, What Doesn't?

Breathing Exercises and Anxiety: What Works, What Doesn't?

Do breathing exercises stop panic attacks and anxiety? How techniques like 4-7-8 and diaphragmatic breathing work, which ones help and which can be risky.

Key Takeaways

  • Breathing exercises can reduce anxiety in the moment, but they are not a stand-alone "treatment" and they do not replace therapy.
  • The common advice to "take a deep breath" during panic does not always work; the problem is not taking in too little air but breathing too much and lowering carbon dioxide.
  • Techniques that involve holding the breath (4-7-8, box breathing) are not suitable for people with asthma, during pregnancy, or for people with low blood pressure or heart conditions.

Breathing is one of the few bodily functions that runs automatically yet can also be consciously controlled. This article looks, for information purposes, at how breathing exercises affect anxiety, where their limits lie and the risks that are often overlooked.

Important warning: If you have chest pain, severe shortness of breath or palpitations, see a doctor first. These symptoms can come from anxiety, but they can also have a heart or lung cause. It is not right to put them down to anxiety without a medical assessment.

What Does Slow Breathing Change in the Body?

During anxiety and stress, the sympathetic branch of the autonomic nervous system switches on: the heart speeds up, blood pressure rises and breathing becomes shallow. Slow, controlled breathing supports the parasympathetic system, which counterbalances this.

At the heart of the mechanism is a simple cycle. When you breathe in, your heart rate rises slightly; when you breathe out, it slows down. When you make the out-breath longer, the slowing effect on the heart lasts longer too. That is why most techniques make the exhale longer than the inhale.

The second point concerns breathing rate. At rest we take between twelve and twenty breaths a minute. When breathing is deliberately slowed, the breathing rhythm, fluctuations in heart rate and oscillations in blood pressure come into step with one another. Known in the literature as resonance frequency, this has a marked effect on heart rate variability.

Some popular explanations in this field (especially those built on polyvagal theory) have been heavily criticised by scientists. By contrast, there is broad agreement that slow breathing and long exhalations increase the parasympathetic influence on the heart.

Why Does Breathing Go Wrong During Panic?

Contrary to what most people think, the feeling of suffocation during panic does not come from a lack of oxygen. It is the other way round.

Fast, shallow breathing lowers the amount of carbon dioxide in the blood. When carbon dioxide drops, the blood's acid-base balance shifts and haemoglobin finds it harder to release the oxygen it carries into the tissues. Carbon dioxide is also a natural dilator of the blood vessels in the brain; when it falls, these vessels narrow and blood flow to the brain is reduced.

Many of the frightening symptoms of a panic attack come from this. Dizziness and light-headedness come from reduced blood flow to the brain; numbness in the hands and around the mouth comes from the shift in acid-base balance making nerve endings more sensitive; and the feeling of unreality also comes from the drop in blood flow to the brain.

These symptoms are often mistaken for a heart attack. Studies of people who go to emergency departments with chest pain but have no heart-related findings have found that, in a significant proportion of them, the underlying problem was a panic attack.

What This Means

The common advice to "take a deep breath" during panic does not always work, and in some cases it can make things worse. The problem is not taking in too little air but breathing too much and lowering carbon dioxide. The point is not to take in lots of air but to steady the pace of breathing.

Commonly Used Techniques

The techniques below are methods described in the literature and seen in clinical practice. They are included here not as recommendations to follow, but to explain what each technique involves.

Slow breathing with a long exhale

Based on making the out-breath longer than the in-breath. Because it involves no breath-holding, it is one of the methods with the fewest restrictions.

Diaphragmatic breathing

Based on breathing into the abdomen rather than the chest. It is the most established technique in the context of relaxation and stress management.

Resonance breathing

Based on slowing breathing to around six breaths a minute. It is an approach that needs regular practice rather than a quick fix in the moment.

Physiological sigh

Based on taking two short breaths in a row and then a long breath out. It involves no breath-holding.

Box breathing

Based on keeping the in-breath, hold, out-breath and pause equal in length. Because it involves holding the breath, it is not suitable for everyone.

The 4-7-8 technique

The technique most widely shared online. Being popular does not make it better than other methods. It involves holding the breath for a long time.

Capnometry-assisted breathing training

Based on monitoring and adjusting carbon dioxide levels in the blood with a device in a clinical setting. It is not something you can do alone at home; it requires a professional and specialised equipment.

Technique Main feature When it is not recommended
Slow breathing Out-breath longer than in-breath, no breath-holding Advanced respiratory disease
Diaphragmatic breathing Abdominal rather than chest breathing No notable restrictions reported
Box breathing Equal phases, includes breath-holding Pregnancy, low blood pressure, people who are afraid of holding their breath
4-7-8 Long breath-hold and long exhale Asthma, pregnancy, heart conditions, low blood pressure

Not Right for Everyone: Limits and Risks

Breathing exercises are usually presented as harmless for everyone. That is not true, and it is the part most online content leaves out.

When trying to relax increases anxiety

Some people with ongoing anxiety feel more anxious, rather than more relaxed, during relaxation exercises. Especially in people who tend to read bodily sensations as threats, turning attention to the breath can backfire: thoughts such as "Am I doing this right?" or "Why is my heart still racing?" can make anxiety grow.

In that case, practices that turn attention towards the outside world may be more suitable than body-focused approaches. This does not mean anything is wrong with the person; it means a different route is needed.

When breathing becomes a safety behaviour

This is the most important warning in the cognitive behavioural therapy literature. Frantically grabbing a breathing exercise as panic starts can send the brain the message that the panic attack really is dangerous and was only survived thanks to the exercise. It brings relief in the short term but feeds the cycle in the long term.

In work on panic disorder, the aim is not to suppress bodily sensations but to learn, through experience, that they are harmless and pass on their own.

A history of trauma

Closing your eyes and focusing inwards on the body can be triggering for people with a history of trauma. That is why body-focused work with these people is done with a professional and in a way that keeps them in control.

Medical conditions

In asthma and COPD, practices that involve deep, rapid breathing can irritate the airways. Techniques that involve holding the breath can lower blood pressure by increasing pressure inside the chest; they are not suitable during pregnancy or for people with low blood pressure or heart rhythm disorders.

Not Everything Called "Breathwork" Is the Same

Two completely different things are grouped under the heading of breathwork, and the difference matters.

The slow breathing techniques covered in this article work to calm the nervous system. In contrast, the Wim Hof method, holotropic breathwork and similar practices are based on minutes of fast, deep breathing, which strongly stimulates the sympathetic system. Their effects are opposite.

There is no established clinical evidence that these methods can be used for anxiety, stress or panic disorder. In a person with anxiety problems, deliberate rapid breathing carries a risk of triggering a panic attack. Temporary loss of consciousness has also been reported with these practices; done in water or while driving, they can lead to serious accidents.

Can It Replace Therapy?

No. Clinical authorities such as NICE and the American Psychological Association do not recommend breathing exercises as a stand-alone treatment for generalised anxiety disorder or panic disorder. The first-line psychological approach for panic disorder is cognitive behavioural therapy.

Breathing work has a supporting role. Changing the thought patterns beneath anxiety and working through avoidance are the work of therapy.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Do breathing exercises make anxiety go away?

They can help reduce anxiety, but they do not eliminate it on their own. Research points to a measurable but limited effect. Immediate effects such as a slower heart rate appear quickly, while a change in overall anxiety levels requires regular, long-term practice.

Why is the 4-7-8 technique so popular?

It is widely known because it has spread so far online. But popularity does not mean scientific superiority; comparative studies suggest that simpler, slow breathing methods can be at least as effective. Because it involves a long breath-hold, it is not suitable during pregnancy or for people with asthma, low blood pressure or heart conditions.

Do breathing exercises help during a panic attack?

It depends on the person. For some, slowing the breath is calming, while for people who focus heavily on bodily sensations, turning to the breath can increase anxiety. And when breathing is used as an escape to avoid feeling the panic, it can make recovery harder in the long run. That is why there is no single piece of advice for the moment of crisis that suits everyone.

Could shortness of breath and palpitations be caused by anxiety?

They could. Anxiety and panic can produce symptoms that resemble heart problems. But the order should be: first a medical assessment, then psychological support once heart and lung causes have been ruled out. Nothing on this page replaces a medical assessment.

Can constantly trying to breathe deeply be harmful?

It can. Constantly trying to breathe deeply and take in more air lowers carbon dioxide in the blood; this narrows the blood vessels supplying the brain and can cause dizziness, numbness and an even stronger feeling of suffocation. The point is not to take in lots of air but to steady the pace of breathing.

Can breathing exercises replace therapy?

No. Clinical guidelines position breathing work not as a stand-alone treatment but as a supporting element. Evidence-based psychotherapy is needed to address the thought patterns underlying anxiety.

Disclaimer: The information on this page is for general information only; it does not replace a medical or psychological assessment, diagnosis or treatment, and it is not a set of instructions. If you notice the symptoms described in this article in yourself or someone close to you, you are advised to see a doctor and a mental health professional.

If you have a known heart, blood pressure or breathing condition, or if you are pregnant, consult your doctor before starting breathing exercises.

Psychologist Ethem Tozbay

Psychologist Ethem Tozbay

A graduate of Mersin University, Department of Psychology, Ethem Tozbay works with a Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) approach on anxiety disorders, depression and relationship problems, in person in Eskişehir and online. He is a member of the Turkish Psychological Association and bases his work on evidence-based methods.

In person: Atılgan Plaza, Odunpazarı, EskişehirOnline sessions across TürkiyeFree first consultation

Eskişehir Psychologist Ethem Tozbay - Online Appointment

Take the First Step

"On this journey of psychological support that we will set out on together, I will walk alongside you and always be by your side, so that you can overcome every difficulty you may meet along the way.

On this journey, in which there will be sad moments as well as happy ones, we will get past every obstacle and every unknown together. We are in this together..."